Tag Archives: Surface Transportation Reauthorization

How AnnaLeah & Mary’s Story Is Making Truck Crashes More Survivable

On May 4, 2013, AnnaLeah and Mary were riding with their mom, Marianne, and their brother, Caleb, to their siblings’ college graduations and oldest sister’s wedding. All of their hopes and dreams came to a screeching halt when a truck failed to slow down, hit their car, and sent them backwards into the rear of a tractor trailer. The rear underride guard came off the truck and the car slid underneath. AnnaLeah, in the back seat, had the breath of life knocked out of her — killed by blunt force trauma and mechanical asphyxia. Her sister, Mary, suffered life-threatening injuries and died a few days later, on May 8, in a hospital. 

The girls’ mother and brother in the front seat were spared catastrophic injuries because their part of the car did not go under the truck.

The crash that killed AnnaLeah and Mary is considered an underride crash.  An underride crash occurs when a passenger vehicle slides under the body of a tractor-trailer as the Karth’s car did when it was spun around.  At the time of the crash, the rear underride guard on the trailer met the federal standard. But it failed to prevent underride and, like the guards on millions of other trailers, was proven to be too weak by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.  In addition, side and front guards, which would also help mitigate these crashes, are not required in the US.

Countless words and circumstances bring my daughters to mind. Their humor, joy-of-living, and insight filled our days. ⚜ Marianne Karth

Read Mary’s story here.

Read AnnaLeah’s story here.

Since the day they lost their daughters, AnnaLeah and Mary’s parents, Jerry and Marianne Karth, have worked tirelessly to prevent other families from experiencing a similar loss. Marianne is a national leader and advocate for underride protection. She regularly organizes national meetings, conferences, and crash tests, bringing together fellow victims, experts, engineers, federal regulators, and the trucking industry to work on comprehensive underride protection. 

The Karths are asking you to join them as they bring together voices from around the country, who will put pressure on Congress to mandate this commonsense engineering solution. What can you do to help make truck crashes more survivable?

  • Contact your Members of Congress, your two U.S. Senators and your U.S. Representative here. Ask them to take these specific actions:
    • Co-sponsor the STOP Underrides Act of 2027 when it is introduced in early 2027.
    • Communicate with the Senate Commerce Committee, the House Transportation & Infrastructure Committee, and the House Oversight Committee with the following messages –
      • The Committees should include a strong underride mandate in the 2027 Surface Transportation Reauthorization Bill.
      • The Committees should exercise their oversight authority by holding an Underride Hearing.
  • Tell your legislators that you would like to meet with them via Zoom to discuss this matter of importance to you. The Karths are available to assist you in setting these meetings up and participating with you — as Team Underride — in these discussions. Reach out to the Karths today: marianne@annaleahmary.com.

Can Conflicting Conclusions in Side Underride Guard CBAs BOTH Be Correct?

What will Congress and NHTSA do with conflicting conclusions from two side underride guard cost benefit analyses? After all, they can’t both be correct, can they? The answer matters for thousands of road users who may otherwise lose their lives in future collisions with the sides of tractor-trailers.

In 2023, NHTSA issued an Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) for side impact (underride) guards. The cost benefit analysis, which was not externally peer-reviewed, concluded that 17.2 lives would be saved per year, that the annual discounted cost would be between $970 million and $1.2 billion, with a resulting cost per equivalent life saved ranging between $73.5 million to $103.7 million. They therefore determined that a side impact guard regulation would not be cost-effective.

In contrast, Eric Hein, a retired federal scientist, published a double-blind, peer-reviewed cost benefit analysis study in the Journal of Progress in Safety & Security on May 15, 2026, titled, Cost-benefit analysis of side underride guards for new semitrailers in the United States. Hein concludes,

In every modeled scenario, preventing 50 to 150 fatalities and comparable numbers of serious injuries produces positive present value net economic benefits. Estimated net benefits range from $0.137 billion to $2.8 billion and consistently exceed the combined costs of side underride guard installation and the fuel penalty attributable to added weight.

These two one-pagers, created by Hein, summarize the results of his study:

Side Underrride CBA Policy Brief

Side Underride Hidden Legal Costs

NHTSA requested comments on their 2023 Side Impact Guard ANPRM Regulatory Analysis:

The agency requests comments that would help NHTSA assess and make judgments on the benefits, costs, and other impacts of side underride guards to increase protection for occupants of passenger vehicles in crashes into the sides of trailers and semitrailers. This ANPRM summarizes NHTSA’s research and requests comment on the accuracy of the estimated benefits, costs, and other impacts of requiring side underride guards on heavy trailers and semitrailers.

In response to NHTSA’s request for Public Comments, numerous individuals and organizations questioned the accuracy of NHTSA’s conclusions. That included this excerpt from a comment submitted by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety:

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) believes NHTSA’s analysis suffers from several fundamental flaws that reduce its benefit estimates for side underride guards. Specifically, we estimate the number of lives that could be saved by a side underride guard standard is up to ten times the number reported by NHTSA. . .

The LTCCS-derived estimates for relevant fatalities are roughly 9-13 times the 17.2 lives NHTSA
estimated could be saved by a standard. Interestingly, the agency estimated the costs of a rule to be “6-9 times as large as the corresponding estimated safety benefits.” Establishing how many of these crashes may overwhelm side guard designs and still allow fatal underride would require higher speed crash testing of different potential designs and a better estimate of real-world crash severity in side underride crashes, including a reasonable distribution of impact angles. Even after applying a realistic upper severity limit for guard effectiveness, the available EDR data suggest a side underride guard regulation would be close to the cost effectiveness threshold established by NHTSA using passenger vehicle occupants alone. The true benefits will only be larger once the agency accounts for the number of pedestrians, bicyclists, and motorcyclists whose lives could be saved by side underride guards.

In conclusion, IIHS believes side underride guards have the potential to save many more lives than NHTSA has estimated in its cost-benefit analysis. We urge the agency to perform a more thorough analysis that does not depend on multiple assumptions that guards will provide no benefit outside a narrow range of conditions. Large truck side underride crashes result in hundreds of lost lives and debilitating injuries each year. Equipping trailers with side underride guards would immediately and significantly reduce this unacceptable toll.

Now that NHTSA has received multiple public comments questioning the accuracy of their cost benefit analysis, what are they going to do? Will they pay heed to the Public Comment submitted to NHTSA in 2016 by the Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association (TTMA) in response to a 2014 petition for underride rulemaking? TTMA President Jeff Sims concludes that comment with this commitment,

TTMA would support the implementation of side impact guards if they ever become justified and technologically feasible. We continue to support the NHTSA review of Petitioners’ requests and stand ready to partner in the development of justified and feasible designs if they possibly emerge.

Hein referenced his study in a recent opinion piece published on June 4 in The Hill, Federal regulators know exactly how to prevent side underride deaths. Hein concludes with a reminder and recommendation to Congress regarding its role in ending preventable underride tragedies.

In 2021, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act directed National Highway Traffic Safety Administration to assess the feasibility, benefits and costs of side underride guards and determine whether performance requirements were warranted. The agency issued an advance notice of proposed rulemaking in April 2023, but its analysis left out major categories of preventable harm. It did not count side underride deaths involving pedestrians, bicyclists and motorcyclists, and it excluded crashes above 40 miles per hour, even though the government’s own research shows side guards can be effective up to 50 miles per hour. 

Congress required a decision, not endless review. More than three years later, the agency has not finished the job, still stuck reviewing comments. The rulemaking has not advanced. 

Since the 1970s, the National Transportation Safety Board has urged the agency to address underride protection. Its Advisory Committee on Underride Protection recently reached a similar conclusion, reporting that “in the last 50 years no substantial progress has been made by [The Department of Transportation] to prevent these horrific crash fatalities and injuries.” Yet the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration continues to delay while families keep losing loved ones in crashes that can be prevented. 

The agency does not need perfect data to act. Federal safety regulation often proceeds under uncertainty when the risk is severe, the countermeasure is feasible and the evidence supports action. 

The trucking industry has often said side underride guards should be required only if they are technologically feasible and economically justified. Those conditions have now been met. Crash tests and real-world deployments show the technology can work. 

Congress should include the Stop Underrides Act in the next surface transportation reauthorization and finally require side underride guards on new semitrailers.

Side impact guards have been shown to be both technologically feasible and cost-justified. What are we waiting for?